Cure of ASPS with Lung Mets - What Treaments in Common?
Posted: Sun Dec 23, 2007 11:04 pm
Olga and any others, please add your comments on this post. Is this an accurate summary of the common features of ASPS patients with lung mets who seems to have a complete remission / cure?
From what I've been able to review here and case reports: all patients who have been cured of stage IV ASPS (primary + lung mets), they all had the following in common:
1. Primary out.
2. Sometimes pre-thoracotomy chemo
3. Thoracotomy on one side
4. Thoracotomy on other
5. Chemo x 36 weeks to 2 1/2 years (prolonged).
The cases include 2 case reports:
1. (Nickerson article in your library): 13 year old - no evid disease 10 years out from diagnosis - primary out, 2 cycles chemo (12 weeks), thoracotomy 1, thoracotomy 2, 36 weeks of chemo.
Agents: vincristine, cytoxan, mens, doxo; alt with etoposide, ifos x 6. Surgery removed 13 nodules L, 11 on R.
2. (Baum: http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi- ... 1/PDFSTART) 14 yo - no evidence disease 5 years from diagnosis-
primary out, thoracotomy 1(40 mets), thoracotomy 2 (52 nodules), 2 years of outpatient chemo. vincristine, actinomycin D, cytoxan, doxorubicin.
3. Camilla - 24 years from diagnosis-
primary out, chemo, thoracotomies, chemo x 2 1/2 years.
adria, cisplatin, DTIC
4. Tammy - 22 years from diagnosis-
primary out, XRT, chemo, thoracotomies, chemo
vincristine, actinomycin, cytoxan, adriamycin, cisplatin
5. Amanda - 6 years from diagnosis-
primary out, thoracotomies x 2, recurrence of mets, chemo.
celebrex + vinblastine x 8 mos, celebrex x 1 year, 3 rounds of ? AIM
Radioablation, VATS etc seems preferable to thoracotomy, but the risk is that thoracotomy may be a better way to increase the risk of cure. The other thing I notice looking at this list is how long chemotherapy needed to be given. There is a lot of interest in metronomic chemotherapy - lower daily doses of chemo that is better tolerated and may improve the kill of slower dividing cancers like ASPS.
When I look at the above, I'm thinking it supports being aggressive early - certainly in terms of duration of chemo - if a complete cure is hoped for.
From what I've been able to review here and case reports: all patients who have been cured of stage IV ASPS (primary + lung mets), they all had the following in common:
1. Primary out.
2. Sometimes pre-thoracotomy chemo
3. Thoracotomy on one side
4. Thoracotomy on other
5. Chemo x 36 weeks to 2 1/2 years (prolonged).
The cases include 2 case reports:
1. (Nickerson article in your library): 13 year old - no evid disease 10 years out from diagnosis - primary out, 2 cycles chemo (12 weeks), thoracotomy 1, thoracotomy 2, 36 weeks of chemo.
Agents: vincristine, cytoxan, mens, doxo; alt with etoposide, ifos x 6. Surgery removed 13 nodules L, 11 on R.
2. (Baum: http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi- ... 1/PDFSTART) 14 yo - no evidence disease 5 years from diagnosis-
primary out, thoracotomy 1(40 mets), thoracotomy 2 (52 nodules), 2 years of outpatient chemo. vincristine, actinomycin D, cytoxan, doxorubicin.
3. Camilla - 24 years from diagnosis-
primary out, chemo, thoracotomies, chemo x 2 1/2 years.
adria, cisplatin, DTIC
4. Tammy - 22 years from diagnosis-
primary out, XRT, chemo, thoracotomies, chemo
vincristine, actinomycin, cytoxan, adriamycin, cisplatin
5. Amanda - 6 years from diagnosis-
primary out, thoracotomies x 2, recurrence of mets, chemo.
celebrex + vinblastine x 8 mos, celebrex x 1 year, 3 rounds of ? AIM
Radioablation, VATS etc seems preferable to thoracotomy, but the risk is that thoracotomy may be a better way to increase the risk of cure. The other thing I notice looking at this list is how long chemotherapy needed to be given. There is a lot of interest in metronomic chemotherapy - lower daily doses of chemo that is better tolerated and may improve the kill of slower dividing cancers like ASPS.
When I look at the above, I'm thinking it supports being aggressive early - certainly in terms of duration of chemo - if a complete cure is hoped for.